California Immigration

Widow penalty to end

by

The infamous “Widow’s Penalty” once cruelly denied permanent residency to non-citizen spouses. Their U.S. citizen partner died before their two-year wedding anniversary. This policy forced grieving individuals into deportation.

Fortunately, Congress ended this injustice in 2009. Now, widows and widowers can self-petition for a green card using Form I-360 within two years of their spouse’s death. This applies regardless of the marriage duration, provided the marriage was bona fide.

widow penalty

The “Widow Penalty” — what it was, what changed, and how surviving spouses can proceed

Historically, U.S. immigration policy created a harsh result sometimes called the “widow penalty”: surviving spouses whose U.S. citizen spouse died within two years of marriage faced automatic denial of marriage-based immigration benefits in many cases. That policy was substantially changed by statute and agency practice so that surviving spouses now have specific paths to seek lawful permanent residence — but timing, eligibility rules, and filing options matter.

Quick summary — the practical rules today

  • A widow or widower of a U.S. citizen may be eligible for a green card through a special pathway (self-petition as a widow(er) or conversion of a pending/approved petition), rather than being automatically barred by the old two-year rule.
  • If the U.S. citizen spouse filed an I-130 before death, USCIS has statutory and policy mechanisms that may allow survivors to continue processing—subject to deadlines and eligibility checks. 

Who qualifies

  • Married to the U.S. citizen at time of death (not divorced or legally separated).
  • File the correct petition (often Form I-360) within applicable time limits or qualify to preserve a pending/approved I-130 under USCIS policy.

Immediate actions

  1. Preserve marriage and death certificates, I-130 receipts/approvals, passports, and proof the marriage was bona fide.
  2. Confirm filing deadlines and notify USCIS if an I-130 was pending or approved.
  3. Screen for other bars (criminal/fraud/prior removals) that could require waivers.

Common pathways

  • I-360 Self-Petition (Widow(er)) — file if eligible; follow adjustment or consular processing steps depending on location and visa availability. 
  • Conversion / Humanitarian Reinstatement — where an I-130 was filed before death, USCIS policy and statutory provisions may permit continued processing or reinstatement; these are fact-specific remedies. 

Contact Form